Rental fraud is no longer a one-off problem. It’s a widespread and systemic issue that property managers need to address now.

As recently investigated in a Wall Street Journal article, Atlanta has become the epicenter of a surge in rental-application fraud. The average two-bedroom apartment in the city costs nearly $2,000 per month, well above what many residents can realistically afford. As demand outpaces supply, some applicants are turning to falsified documents, fake pay stubs, and even fabricated employment letters to get approved for units they couldn’t normally afford. 

While this isn’t a brand new problem, social media, AI tools, and “fraud-as-a-service” marketplaces have made it easier than ever to create convincing fake applications. Influencers on TikTok are openly promoting methods to boost approval odds by falsifying financial information, including selling complete “apartment packages” with fake social security numbers and near-perfect credit profiles.

Snappt’s internal database confirms this trend: fraudulent document attempts rose 36% year-over-year, with Atlanta, South Florida, Houston, and the D.C. metro area seeing the sharpest increases. In some Atlanta communities, over 45% of applications show signs of document tampering.

“Fraudsters are leveraging AI to fake documentation, and we’re using AI to stop them,” Kyle Nelson, VP of Corporate Strategy at Snappt, shared with Deborah Acosta and Rebecca Picciotto of The Wall Street Journal. “It’s a constant cycle of innovation, but one that ultimately protects operators, residents, and the integrity of the housing market.” 

Quick Insights

• Atlanta’s housing market—with high rents and a glut of luxury apartments—is a prime target for fraud.
• Advanced AI and accessible digital tools make it easier to falsify income, employment, and identity documents.
• Fraud directly affects operators’ bottom lines through unpaid rent, evictions, and operational disruption.
• Traditional manual screening methods are no longer sufficient.

Why Rental Fraud is Rising

High-demand rental markets like Atlanta are putting more pressure on applicants. Many are rejected for legitimate reasons, such as bad credit, previous evictions, or insufficient income. To overcome these barriers, applicants turn to devious methods. 

AI, Photoshop, and even friends posing as landlords or employers make it easy to create fake references, payment histories, or employment letters. Once approved for a property, these tenants often stop paying rent, creating financial and operational headaches for property managers.

The Real Cost for Property Managers

Fraud isn’t just an inconvenience. It’s expensive.

• Financial impact: Evictions can cost thousands, and fraudulent tenants increase write-offs and bad debt.
• Operational costs: Leasing teams spend time verifying fraudulent applications instead of focusing on legitimate tenants.
• Reputational risk: Fraudsters in your property can disrupt communities, leading to negative experiences and reviews.

Technology is the Key to Staying Ahead

Manual verification methods simply don’t cut it anymore, despite over 40% of property managers using that as their primary line of defense. The most successful operators use AI tools combined with a human-in-the-loop approach to catch these manipulated documents without slowing down their processes. 

One area of the leasing process frequently overlooked is verifying rental payment history. Adding this step not only leads to faster leasing and higher occupancy, but it also catches an additional 5-8% of fraudulent applications that traditional screening misses.

Snappt’s Verification of Rent (VOR) feature can help during this stage:

• Intelligent Outreach: Multi-channel follow-up via email, text, and phone.
• Landlord Verification: Confirms legitimacy by cross-referencing property ownership databases before contact.
• 80%+ Success Rate: Exceeds the industry average for rental payment verification.

Rewriting Your Screening Playbook for a Fraud-Heavy Market

As fraud evolves and becomes increasingly difficult to spot, sticking with outdated verification methods is fighting a losing battle. If your leasing process still depends on manual calls or applicant-supplied references, it’s time to rethink your approach and adopt a “trust but verify” mindset. Building trust with applicants is important, but protecting your properties and residents comes first.

Modern screening should operate in layers, with each stage adding another line of defense against fraud. Start with identity verification to confirm that applicants are who they say they are. Then, verify income (via bank linking, connected payroll, or document upload) to ensure pay stubs, bank statements, or employment letters haven’t been manipulated.

Next, review rental payment history to validate that an applicant has a record of consistent, on-time payments. This step is often ignored, yet it’s one of the strongest indicators of whether a renter will meet their lease obligations. Finally, document fraud detection tools should be used to identify signs of digital tampering or inception fraud that traditional checks can’t catch.

When these layers work together, they form a comprehensive shield that prevents fraud from slipping through the cracks. The result is a faster, more accurate process that protects your community and reduces costly evictions or bad debt. It’s all about working smarter—using data and automation to make confident, informed leasing decisions that protect your properties and your peace of mind.

Bottom Line

It’s time to accept that fraudulent documents and references aren’t a passing fad: they’re part of a broader, industry-wide shift in rental fraud. The good news is that property managers who modernize their screening processes will be better equipped to protect their portfolios, reduce financial risk, and maintain safe, thriving communities.

Tools like Snappt’s Applicant Trust Platform help bridge the gap between traditional methods and sophisticated fraud tactics. The key is finding robust fraud solutions that integrate into your existing workflow and give you the confidence that every application has been thoroughly vetted.

Because at Snappt, we fight fire with fire—using advanced AI and automation to outsmart the very technology fraudsters rely on.

Don’t miss our upcoming webinar on Verification of Rent to learn how we automate rental payment history checks, saving leasing teams hours while adding a powerful layer of fraud prevention.

Ready to protect your properties?

Chat with our sales team to learn about our comprehensive fraud solution

Let’s Talk